To be honest I kind of like all of them I have well not so much the coconut (as its very strongly scented and a tad feminine for my preferences) - but I don't think I'd be looking to trade/sell any as the replacement costs are a PITA for one or two and thats all I'd need. Sorry mate.
I got someone to got halves with me in ordering some, thats not a bad strategy - he's actually pretty generous with his shipping allowances etc so I found that worked well.
PS. FWIW Barber's Shop is not too bad...quite sweet, definitely true to it's name - dunno if I would order it again but it's solid.
Bay Rum is the best I tried BY FAR - I got around 5 soaps plus a whole bunch of samplers before this. It's just really nice - has a very nice spice to it to compliment the Bay Laurel.
Lime is my go-to hot day shaving soap. Lathers the best of any of his and is very refreshing to use. That said Lime is a very common scent and I dunno if I'd get it again and not something a tad more exotic e.g Peppermint+Rosemary (tried in samplers and was good).
Orange/Cedar/Pepper is good - happy with that, perhaps just a tad too much Orange but it's still good. Pine+ Cedarwood was an interesting sampler, quite masculine and unlike stuff we get here in Oz.
The Lemongrass+Euca sounded great but I was underwhelmed. Like I said the Coconut is overpowering, I regret getting it. I wasn't a fan of the Hungarian Lavender either (only sampler), bit too full on for me.
I do regret not getting the Vetiver, it was more expensive than the rest and a trial production when I ordered but it sounds the business.
Overall I found some of the scents a bit much and sometimes the lathers only so-so but they always shave beautifully and like I said NOTHING else not even MWF is even close for how your skin feels after use - honestly compare the ingredients to any other top end soaps and these have way more high end oils/butters than anythng else I've seen.