@khun_diddy , FWIW the most commonly used Lye Calculator (dunno if
@bald as told you what one of these are - essentially an online spreadsheet that does all the number crunching of how much of this to mix with how much of that to make soaps), Soap Calc has a default fragrance/EO % of 3.1%.
Now obviously some folks might like it stronger or weaker - and certain EO's are either stronger or weaker (for example put in 3% Eucalyptus or Tea Tree and it will be WAY too strong). But that % is recommended for CP soaps, who lose a lot of their scent as the scents are added while saponification is still occurring and they then have to cure for many weeks...........so I'm very surprised that your scents were too weak.
As one of the big advantages in doing HP soaps is that they require a lot less scent compounds, which is often 30-50% of the overall costs - so I'd have thought 2% would be about right (depending on the EO's used).
Are you allowing the soap to cool down quite a bit before you add the EO's? As most of them are volatile oils and adding while the soaps are still too hot will see you losing a lot of the EO just like if you were putting it in an oil burner/vapouriser.
- What % superfat did you guys go with? Did you 'select' your SF oil by adding after saponification or was the glycerine the only thing you added post-trace?
- KOH only or some NaOH as well?
- Did you cook it in a double boiler/waterbath or something else?
Interested to know the specifics of what you went with as my new stuff is just asking to be used. ;-)