Proraso Green is good and if you can still find it in supermarkets _ Gaia organic ASB
Oh if the balm smells anything like the soap, then that CRSW Fall 2015 would be spot-on. Have you got a full pot or only a sample....as I'd be keen on the ingredients mate (if possible)?I have never used that many after shave balms. My favourites are CRSW fall balm and Shaver Heaven 1st Anniversary balm.
My current fave:
Myrsol Emulsion